The Test of Tebow

Tim Tebow

Image by Jeffrey Beall via Flickr

Lately there has been quite a stir on the internet about Tim Tebow, the professional football player that so many love to hate. Ever since he’s come into the spotlight a few years ago, I’ve honestly been surprised and made uncomfortable at some of the irrational hatred directed towards Tebow. A few weeks back, George Weigel voiced what I’ve often wondered:

No, Tim Tebow is a target of irrational hatred, not because he’s an iffy quarterback at the NFL level, or a creep personally, or an obnoxious, in-your-face, self-righteous proselytizer. He draws hatred because he is an unabashed Christian, whose calmness and decency in the face of his Christophobic detractors drives them crazy. Tim Tebow, in other words, is a prime example of why Christophobia—a neologism first coined by a world-class comparative constitutional law scholar, J.H.H. Weiler, himself an Orthodox Jew—is a serious cultural problem in these United States.

While I’ve thought this, I never wanted to express it out of fear of looking like a christian with a persecution complex. But hatred for Tebow because of his religious convictions is really out there, it’s not something that we can just dismiss. Take for instance this ugly, hate filled rant by Jeff Pearlman (who has written for Sports Illustrated and

Tim Tebow scares me, and judging from his father’s website, his upcoming Super Bowl ad and mounting knowledge of his way of life, he should scare you, too. Tim Tebow doesn’t play football merely for the joy of the game. He plays football because he wants to spread the word of Jesus Christ. But not merely spread it. He wants you to accept it and, if you don’t embrace it, he wants you to think again about embracing it. And, if you still don’t embrace it, he wants you to think again. And again. And again. If, in the end, you’re still not sold, you will burn in hell. This is not merely Tim Tebow’s opinion ”but he knows it, in his soul and heart and mind. Christians who accept Jesus will spend an eternity in bliss. Those who don’t are doomed.

Some call this faith.

I call it f***ing insanity.

I know, I know ”everyone has a right to believe what they want … faith is admirable … you’ve gotta respect his feelings. Well, bulls***.

I do not have to respect this sort of damaging craziness, where a group of people go to foreign, oft-Third World nations and convert the so-thought-of “savages” (ie: those who don’t know Christ).

Forgive the expletives and straw men. I suppose I can appreciate Pearlman’s honesty. Don’t misunderstand me, it would be absurd to say that everyone who hates Tebow hates him because he did a pro-life Super Bowl ad with Focus on the Family, or that he said he was going to save himself for marriage, or that he does missionary work and puts scriptures on his eye black.

I’m sure there are a ton of people who dislike him for the same reason they dislike Brett Favre. Call it media-fatigue syndrome. People simply get annoyed of hearing how “he wears his heart on his sleeve” and “he just knows how to win”. As a fan of the St. Louis Cardinals, I can sympathize. The fanbase falls in love with just about every undersized hustling scrub that dons the birds on the bat. (see Eckstein, David) I’ve come to loath the adjectives “scrappy”, “gritty” “little things” and “hustle” when they come out of people’s mouths.  Dealing with fans of those players makes me tired.

But can we just admit that some — like Jeff Pearlman and his merry band of followers for instance — despise Tim Tebow because he is an outspoken evangelical Christian? Or to put it more mildly, can’t we just confess that some fans would dislike Tebow just a bit less if he shared their same worldview? What if he was the same player, but was very outspoken about animal rights, or gay marriage, etc.? Sports tends to bring out our irrationality, but I’ve seen too much mockery, derision and just plain venom spewed in his direction for comfort.

I will grant that I believe that because Tebow is so outspoken about controversial issues does open himself to criticism. I think every person’s worldview is up for debate and should be tested on its logical consistency, correspondence to reality, explanatory scope and power, etc. But far too often this isn’t the case, rather we get the really bizarre and irrational disgust and disdain. Or often I see that “he should just keep his beliefs more private”, but these people are often not private about their own beliefs, like the belief that Christians or pro-lifers should keep their mouth shut.

For Christians, I think Tebow presents us with a challenge and an opportunity to discuss our faith, or the Christian perspective on the abortion issue and premarital sex. In case you haven’t noticed, here in ‘merica a lot of people pay attention to football, and many that don’t at least pretend to around the lunch table. And these people very likely have an opinion about Tebow.

If it comes up, I believe we should come right out and ask why it is that  they don’t like him. If they bring up some of his convictions, ask them what about his convictions they disagree with. Hopefully you’ve done your homework and obeyed 1 Peter 3:15, which says “but in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect”

If you haven’t, well…get with it. There are a ton of places on the internet where Christians can begin to become equipped to make the case for Christianity and handle some of the toughest objections critics can raise. There’s really no excuse for Christians to not be able to offer reasons for their faith. Being the lightening rod that Tebow is, he’s given believers an open door to get into the game in the field of sharing our faith, if you can pardon the terrible pun. I believe that is pretty much what Tebow is going for.

6 thoughts on “The Test of Tebow

  1. Pingback: Suspicion Confirmed: Why America Loves to Hate Tim Tebow « Josiah Concept Ministries

  2. i’m a born-again christian, and I don’t think I’ve ever encountered “christophobia”. I also am not a fan of Tim Tebow. I’m sure that he’s personally a great guy and I hope his walk with God is as strong as he says he is, but he’s making a mistake so many christians make. Evangelism is not standing on the street corner and telling people it’s a sin to masturbate (that happens every year at my college). It is living your faith in public. Be willing to answer hard questions from atheist friends, and loving people unselfishly. More importantly than projecting christianity, is living like Christ. Honestly, having scripture on your face isn’t meaningful evangelism. Making a multi-million-dollar ad about abortion isn’t spreading the gospel, its political propaganda.

    I know non-christians who believe Christianity is a scam. All they know about the Gospel is fire and brimstone, that they are unspeakably evil sinners and condemned because their family doesn’t practice the “right” faith. That’s reflected in Pearlman’s over-the-top attitutde. However, if you can talk to them about Jesus they are much more receptive. Most people have positive opinions about Jesus. They just might not think he’s God.

    So I’d encourage people who want to talk about their faith to share it with people they know, to focus on the Gospels, to study other religions and atheism, and to study historical and textual criticism of the Bible (for example the Jesus Seminar). Read Francis Schaffer and Frank Schaffer. And please avoid sanctifying pop-icons who happen to be Christian, when so many martyrs today are dying unrecognized.

    • Dear “born again” ~

      Just a couple respectful reminders: “Love your neighbor as yourself” includes Tim Tebow.
      1 John 4:20 – If anyone says, “I love God,” yet hates his brother, he is a liar. For anyone who does not love his brother, whom he has seen, cannot love God, whom he has not seen.

      Hebrews 3:13 – But encourage one another daily, as long as it is called Today, so that none of you may be hardened by sin’s deceitfulness. 1 Thessalonians 5:11- Therefore encourage one another and build each other up…

      Be sure to encourage what the bible teaches. Yes, we have many examples of Jesus and others teaching one on one. We also have many examples of Jesus and others speaking to thousands at a time.

      Tim speaks on many topics because he’s called. Satan is testing him knowing he will have to give a public response. Tim is answering only because God is leading him to. I wouldn’t want his position. I have had it before (much smaller scale) and the fall out is always judgement. People prefer to hate the teacher than do what’s needed — Look in a mirror.

      Praying all of us will be blessed with more understanding of each other, but more importantly, more understanding of the Lord!

  3. Pingback: Really Recommended Posts 11/5/11 « J.W. Wartick -"Always Have a Reason"

  4. Great, like, really great post here, Erik. I only found your blog today, but thanks for writing this.

    You highlight a fairly common phenomenon, and also the use to which it can be put. A couple of years ago, Melbourne (where I live) played host the the Global Atheist Convention. Amid all the silliness and hot air, it did actually serve a useful function: it got God into the conversation and made ti that much easier to actually talk about Christianity. I haven’t been following the NFL, but it sounds like Tebow might be able to fulfill a similar function in starting conversations and letting people talk about their own Christian faith. But that’s about as much pressure as I’d put on him – he needn’t be held up as a role model and he can’t really be a witness to your own friends and family. But that is something that each of us can do in person.

  5. Erik,

    A couple things…you beat me to it! I wanted to do a post on Tebow and theism, lol. I think I still will, and I will give you the props you deserve and link to this post.

    Pearlman is way out of line. Tebow is open about his beliefs, but he does not preach and say “convert sinner or to hell with you!” He’s a Christian everyday of his life, but he shows up as football player every Sunday. If Pearlman’s argument holds any water, than we can as Christians be as equally outraged at atheist bus ads that read “There’s probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.” Now I easily could spit, “I do not have to respect this sort of damaging craziness, where a group of people advertise in religious and close-minded areas of the country and deconvert the so-thought-of “delusional and the sufferers of ‘mind viruses'” (ie: those who believe in God)

    Plus, kudos on the point with the Cardinals. I spent my high school years in St. Louis and don’t get me wrong, I love the area, but there is a dogmaticism with Cardinals fans. I grew up outside of Missouri and really am not a fan of baseball. St. Louisians viewed me as an oddity for not being interested in the Cardinals. I appreciate a Cardinals fan that can step back and view the Cardinals with some objectivity.

    Overall, good post

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s